The plethora of Amish fiction books flooding the reading markets are often light and romanticized versions of the Amish sects. For readers with more discriminatory tastes, there are Amish autobiographies, better-than-formula fiction, and a new soon-to-be released fiction book based on a former Amish man, which offer honest interpretations of being Amish.
My philosophy about Amish reading? I prefer Amish books which offer deeper characterizations, better insight, and less romanticized stories about the Amish. In these books I find greater satisfaction involving complex human dilemmas and honest questions about being Amish.
If you're looking for Amish reads like that, too, here a few books I can recommend:
I haven't read these next two books yet, but they are on my future reading lists:
Dale Cramer's Amish themed books better reads than most standard formula Amish fiction.
Evie Yoder Miller.
Alice Jay Wisler, Still Life in Shadows. Her novel is based on the life story of Mose Gingerich, who has been featured in several National Geographic television documentaries.
So if Amish is your preferred genre, but you're looking for reads that stray from the typical bonnet books, try some of the books listed above. Freelich lesen!